Imperial Paradise? |
|||||
Captain James Cook undertook three
Voyages of Discovery between 1768 and 1779
under the British flag. These voyages took place within
the context of eighteenth-century European scientific
curiosity. While Cooks voyage to the West Coast of
what is now Canada did not include violent colonisation,
the observations and studies of the Europeans he brought
with him contributed to the legitimisation of imperial
expansion. As many scholars now argue, no observations are made with access to complete truth and objectivity, and as a result they are intricately bound up in relations of power and of knowing.1 |
|||||
The positioning of the statue of Captain
Cook in the inner harbour of Victoria, facing the Empress
Hotel, underscores his centrality to a European
understanding of the land that Victoria was constructed
on. When the Cooks ships the Resolution and the Discovery anchored in Nootka Bay 30 March 1778, Captain Cook was by no means the first European to discover what is now the West Coast of Canada. In 1774, Juan P�rez a Spanish explorer, sailed the same waters in the Santiago and by 1784, Russians had already established a permanent settlement on Kodiak Island after almost 40 years of exploring what is now Alaska. Given these previous encounters between Europeans and First Nations people, the importance of Cooks voyage for the British was not discovering them, but claiming them as part of Britains expanding empire. |
|||||
While
Cooks log books and journals, and those of his
crew, brought some information about the lands and people
that they had encountered, it was Captain George
Vancouver who, in a later voyage, returned to map the
lands. Originally, Vancouver sailed as Cooks
Midshipman on the Discovery. By mapping, he played
a significant role in the physical colonisation of the
island that bears his name. Today, Vancouvers gold-leafed
statue stands on the British Columbia Legislature,
surveying the surrounding land. Both Cook and Vancouver played consequential roles in the expansion of the British Empire. Accordingly, we have included excerpts, both dated 30 March 1778, from their journals. The quotations highlight their attitudes toward and impressions of the people of Nootka Bay, upon meeting them for the first time. |
|||||
According to Captain Cook: We no sooner drew near the inlet than we found the coast to be inhabited and the people came off to the Ships in Canoes without shewing the least amount of fear or distrust. We had at one time thirty two Canoes filled with people about us, and a groupe of ten or a dozen remained along side the Resolution most part of the night. They seemed to be a mild inoffensive people, shewed great readiness to part with any thing they had and took whatever was offered them in exchange, but were more desireous of iron than any thing else, the use of which they very well knew and had several tools and instruments that were made of it.2 |
According to
Midshipman George Vancouver: When we first Entered this Sound at about 5 PM several Canoes came out to the ships and In them a set of the dirtiest beings ever beheld their faces and Hair being a lump of red and black Earth and Grease Their Bodys covered with the Skins of Animals... In the Canoe that first came Along side was a Man that stood up and held forth a long while at the same time pointing to the Sound as if the ship should go further Up his oratory did not seem to be the best in the world and he appeared to Utter with much difficulty; on his head he wore a kind of hat made of Cane and in shape resembling a bucks head; after having finished his harangue he presented it to Sale as well as several other things, which at once convinced us they were no novices at that business, in return for his hat he had a large Axe and left us quite content.3 |
||||
1. Daniel Clayton, "Captain Cook and the Spaces of Contact at "Nootka Sound." In Reading Beyond Words: Contexts for Native History, Eds. Jennfier S.H. Brown and Elizabeth Vibert (Peterborough, ON: Broadview, 1996): 97. 2. As quoted in Captain James Cook, The Voyage of the Resolution and Discovery 1776-1780, Ed. J. C. Beaglehole, Vol. 3, Part 1 (Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1967): 295-296. 3. As quoted in Captain James Cook, The Voyage of the Resolution and Discovery 1776-1780, 295-296.
|
|||||